An
Interview Between Carl Rogers and Grace London, October, 1983 |
The tape begins towards the end of an introductory comment by Carl: ... Demonstration Interview> ... I don't like that term,
it is an interview in front of a group, but it's an interview for
real, it's not something for show, it is the real thing. So it's a
good thing that it's an interview in front of a group, but not "demonstration",
it sounds as though it's for show. And now I'd like to take a moment to shut the camera out of
my mind, and the microphone and the people and get centred in myself
and maybe you would too, Grace. Carl: OK?
... I don't know what you might like to talk about but I'd be very
willing to listen. Grace: (pause)
I'm just at the moment feeling how afraid I am of talking to you. Carl: Frightened
of me, or frightened of the situation, or both? Grace: In
a way it's both 'cos ... it's like ... me being in this situation
am I forced to, and I mean when like I say "forced" I don't
mean externally, I mean forced in a way to meet with you and also
to meet with myself Carl: So you
have to make yourself ... come forward to meet. Grace: Yeh,
and I'm just thinking how much I avoid doing that. I feel OK. about
meeting people and ... spending a little bit of time with them ...
but there's always a point where I want to run away and I think a
lot of the time I do ... when it feels like it's getting too close. Carl: So you
go a little ways in meeting them but there's some point when you feel
"No ... now we would really meet if we went any further"
and you want to run away. Grace: Yes
... and ... I'm thinking that it's funny it's, I'm not afraid of what
it is in you ... I'm afraid of what's in me and, it's like in a way
that I can con myself about what's in me if I don't meet with you,
if I meet with you I have to give you something of me. Carl: So the
block is not in me, it's that if you go too far you'll reveal something
of you. (pause) Grace: I ..
er .. For a long time I've felt like there, there is this thing in
me and I don't know what it is ... and ... sometimes when I hear other
people talking I... and it's not so much the words that they're using
but the feelings that I can sense in them ... of ... um ... I feel
heavy and I know that their feelings are touching the same kind of
feelings in me. Carl: They're
touching that secret part of you that you don't quite know what it
is. Grace: Mm,
a lot of the time that is hurt or pain and sometimes it's anger as
well. Carl: But
you feel that whatever this is that sort of frightening within is
of negative feelings of pain and hurt and possibly anger. Grace: (nods)
And if I get in touch with them that they will overwhelm me and there's
a fear of getting lost in them somehow and of not being able to find
my way back to the joy that I can feel. Carl: That
if you ever let yourself really live in or feel those feelings, maybe
you'd never find your way back to pleasantness and happiness and joy. Grace: 'Cos
I feel like I can't let go of things like hurt and I can't let go
of things like resentment ... I want to, I want to let go of those
things, but I don't know how, how to do that, so I don't want to explore
them. I feel that if I explore them they will always be with me and
I've kind of learnt to experience joy...but having said that to you
I'm questioning whether it's real. Carl: Makes
you wonder whether maybe the joy would feel more real if you were
able to explore some of those frightening feelings. Grace: (Nods)
(Pause> Carl: But
they are scary. Grace: And
I've put them away for such a long time it seems like Carl: Resentment
and hurt and everything like that have just been kept and pushed down
for a long, long time Grace: And
there's this rational part of me that says that I don't have a right
to feel those things and that I can understand the reasons why the
hurt is there and that I should care for the other person that gave
me that hurt and it's like in caring for the other person I kind of
have to hide the hurt, that, they've caused me. Carl: So you
kind of talk it all away and explain why you shouldn't really feel
those feelings are not necessary ... and you shouldn't feel them in
relation to the person who caused them. Grace: Um
... (laughs) ... I've just realised while you were feeding that back
that I know the person who caused them, or ... (pause) ... hah ...
I feel a bit funny about saying "caused" ... I know how
much ... I think I'm doing it again, I'm taking away everything from
the other person and saying that they didn't cause it ... I'm the
cause ... I was just about to rationalise that I'm the person who
caused it and that they couldn't possibly have caused it, Carl: You
can't feel any blame for that person ... it must be you ... and that
somehow you do feel that resentment and hurt Grace: (Nodding) Carl: ...
and you know the person that it's directed toward. (Pause) Grace: I feel
like I have to put myself in a box that ... (Pause) ... I do, I do
feel the resentment but I don't want to because ... how do you get
rid of the feelings and ... like that? ... and I don't want to live
those feelings Carl: It's
safer to keep it in a box and yet you know very well that you do feel
it and you're scared ... if you feel it, then what? will you ever
get rid of it? Grace: (Nods>
... (Long pause) ... I'd like to tell you the person I feel this for,
and it's ... actually it's not just one person it's my parents, my
mother and my father, but it's more with my mother because she's,
I don't know ... I feel it more or it's awakened more in me with my
mother because she's around and my father isn't. (Pause) ... And ...
I kind of feel like ... I was going to say "they" ... I,
like I trapped myself in the past, somehow, but things that I feel
angry about ... from way back ... and I'm still stuck there and I
can't move on until I've dealt with it, but I don't know how to do
that. Carl: So you
know it's your mother mostly, and you know the feelings that were
stirred up, were stirred up a long time ago, but how you can work
through those, that you're not quite clear. Grace: (Nods)
... (Pause) ... And now that causes me to ... er ... not be me ...
I, I think about those things I said to my mother like "I love
you and I understand why those things happened" and things like
that, but I've never been able to show her how hurt I feel about it
all. Carl: Again
you can explain it away that there are reasons and so on, it's OK.,
but you've never been able to let her see the hurt and pain that is
in you ... and that somehow that keeps you from being all of you. Grace: I feel
like I have to protect her somehow Carl: Mm,
you've got to care for her Grace: And
so every day I push down the hurt and I push down the anger and I
push down the resentment and I just ... and I'm somebody else Carl: That
your daily task is to push 'em down, push 'em down, push 'em down
and be somebody that isn't quite real. Grace: And
every day I spend time trying to get in touch with the feelings that
I know are there but are so far away, and so I'm stuck in the past
thinking "Oh! I can't relate to this person because I'm afraid
of, of these feelings inside me and that's all because of these feelings
that happened in the past and if only I could feel the feelings but
I can't and ..." Carl: So you
see it all very clearly, but to try to get in touch with, or to express
those feelings of hurt and resentment, that's where you ... can't
do it (A few words unintelligible) Grace: I,
er I get rid of little bits of it on other people, you know you can
do something really simple to me and I can resent it, you know and
I enjoy feeling resentful. Carl: Your
feeling you let out a little bit of it even though you exaggerate
the situation in order to feel that resentment, and it lets out a
little of the resentment from the past. Grace: That's
exactly it, I didn't use the word "exaggeration" but, er,
situations occur sometimes and I exaggerate them so that they can
fit into this pattern so that I can feel the resentment and (laughs> Carl: So you're
quite ingenious in finding ways of expressing bits of it Grace: Yeah
... I am ... (Long pause> ... (Sighs and shakes head) Carl: I wonder
what that shaking of your head means ... It looks like you're saying
"Isn't possible" Grace: I was
saying "Isn't possible" and I was thinking I can't blame,
I can't blame it on anybody that ... and I was thinking I can't ...
um ... I wanted to tell you a bit about what happened and ... but
then I thought that by telling you I'd kind of be blaming it on something
and ... Carl: It's
got to come so carefully that it doesn't blame anybody or anything,
you can't just let it out Grace: That's
what's so awful about it, I know it reminded ... I'm running this
battle somehow with my emotions, but maybe it is OK. to blame and
to say, to get it all out, and then when it's all out maybe I can
do something with it that makes it OK. with everybody concerned, but
... Carl: So it's
quite possible that it's OK. to be unreasonable and irrational even,
spill things that aren't quite right, because when you might then
be able to make it OK. afterwards once they were out. (Pause) Grace: I just
realised something ... part of the hurt is about not being considered
and I'm talking about when I was young and my parents kept on getting
back together again and separating and getting back together again
and separating and I went into a children's home and all sorts of
things that I wasn't considered, and now what I'm doing is not considering
myself, I'm not ... it's like I can't consider myself, I don't think
that I'm important enough to be considered. Carl: That
childhood experience of being shuttled around and not being considered
in the situation ... er ... resulted in you not being able to consider
and take care of yourself ... (Pause> ... and you must have felt
very keenly the business of being treated as an object, just put here,
put there and not really, not really considered, not really cared
about Grace: I mean
how can you say what you want when you're four. (Pause) Carl: How
can you possibly say when you're four years old "Hey! look at
me, I need to be considered, I need to be (hugged?) Grace: (Weeps) Carl: I guess
you're saying and feeling it now ... (Pause) ... and it hurt like
hell. (Pause) Grace: (Blows
nose) ... and even now I can't consider myself, I feel like I've got
to wipe the tears away and talk to you and ... Carl: Don't
have any undue show of emotion ... got to be polite and proper Grace: I always
feel guilty when I'm crying, you know, I always feel that I'm not
allowed to cry. Carl: Don't
cry ... be a big girl ... but when the tears were dropping that was
the four year old feeling very hurt. (Pause) Grace: And
angry, very angry Carl: And
angry (Unintelligible) Damn you, why don't you consider me? Grace: (Wipes
tears) Now my rational mind has come back and I'm saying I understand
how it was with your mother, she's told you a bit about that Carl: So don't
feel those feelings, there were reasons for your mother's actions
... mustn't feel those feelings Grace: She'd
feel very hurt if I ... It's almost like a reverse ... I feel like
I have to mother her sometimes, like I have to reassure her that it's
OK. Carl: You
didn't hurt me Grace: Yeah. Carl: It's
not true, but still you must be a good mother to her. Grace: And
that makes me angry sometimes too. Carl: Why
do I have to be her mother Grace: Yeah
... (Pause) ... I'm frightened now that I might get lost in what I'm
feeling. Carl: It's
scary to let yourself down into those feelings, you might not be able
to get out. Grace: But
it almost feels like self pity and I don't know I can accept that,
that I pity myself or I feel sorry for myself. Carl: You
almost feel ashamed of that but you do feel sorry for yourself. Grace: (Nods> Carl: You
realise "I went through a helluva lot" ... (pause) "I
really do feel pity for myself". Grace: (Laughs)
I've washed it away now. I'm thinking about that time when I was in
the children's home, it was a Catholic home, it was a convent and
they used to say things like that, like, you know, everyone's got
this thing about pity yourself, that you should think about other
people and that was so much around me at the time and I think I really
learnt it very well. Carl: You
just don't feel things like that, you think about other people ...
a good lesson in sitting on your feelings ... You learnt it all too
well. Grace: It
wasn't such a good lesson; I feel good because ... I feel I'm just
beginning to feel those feelings ... I talked about they're coming
out a little by little. Carl: It's
not quite so frightening because you realise "Yes, I an in touch
with them and they're not overwhelming me coming out little by little" (Long
pause) Grace: I somehow
wish I could explore more with you. Carl: You
wish? Grace: I wish
I could explore more with you, because I don't feel frightened with
you Carl: You
feel that this is a fairly safe place, that I'm a fairly safe person. Grace: Yes. Carl: You'd
like to get at more of it. There's the hurt and anger of being shuttled
back and forth and there's the suppression of the convent, the orphanage,
but there are others. Grace: (Nods)
There's a lot more. Carl: A lot
more. Grace: At
the moment I don't feel as frightened as I did, although I'm sure
that that might come back, that fear. Carl: But
for the moment they don't seem quite so scary. Grace: And
that feels like such a relief because, I was just thinking about all
the times that I meet people and how much it stops me from being with
people sometimes. Carl: It's
really good to have that fear lessened a little when it's really stopped
you from some (Unintelligible) (Pause) Grace: And
I think I'm also getting the feeling that what's so bad about telling
other people that I'm hurt? Carl: What's
the big deal, what's the big crime in saying I'm hurt, I am hurting.
Why does that seem so bad? Grace: And
it has (Pause) Grace: I think
perhaps I was trying to be somebody else. Carl: Trying
to be somebody that you were not. Grace: Trying
to be what other people wanted me to be, I think, I think it's all
part of not considering me, and considering other people, what it
is that they want from me, how they want me to be. Carl: So I've
got to be what they would like and not consider me. Grace: I think
I'll be me for a while. Carl: You
think you'll be your for a while did you say? Grace: Yes Carl: Might
be your experiment, huh? Grace: Yes Carl: You'll
really consider yourself and be yourself and not try to be what other
people want you to be. We're going to have to stop in a couple of
minutes ... Would you like to stop now? Grace: Yes Carl: Good. Transcribed by Bob Lusty, October 1990. |