BOX 3.2
An Example of Negative Transfer
Luchins and Luchins (1970) studied how prior experience can limit
people's abilities to function efficiently in new settings. They used
water jar problems where participants had three jars of varying sizes
and an unlimited water supply and were asked to obtain a required amount
of water. Everyone received a practice problem. People in the
experimental group then received five problems (problems 2-6) prior to
critical test problems (7, 8, 10, and 11). People in the control group
went straight from the practice problems to problems 7-11. Problems 2-6
were designed to establish a "set" (Einstellung) for solving the
problems in a particular manner (using containers b-a-2c as a solution).
People in the experimental group were highly likely to use the
Einstellung Solution on the critical problems even though more efficient
procedures were available. In contrast, people in the control group
used solutions that were much more direct.
|
Given Jars of the Following Sizes |
Obtain the Amount |
Problem |
A |
B |
C |
1 |
29 |
3 |
|
20 |
2 Einstellung 1 |
21 |
127 |
3 |
100 |
3 Einstellung 2 |
14 |
163 |
25 |
99 |
4 Einstellung 3 |
18 |
43 |
10 |
5 |
5 Einstellung 4 |
9 |
42 |
6 |
21 |
6 Einstellung 5 |
20 |
59 |
4 |
31 |
7 Critical 1 |
23 |
49 |
3 |
20 |
8 Critical 2 |
15 |
39 |
3 |
18 |
9 |
28 |
76 |
3 |
25 |
10 Critical 3 |
18 |
48 |
4 |
22 |
11 Critical 4 |
14 |
36 |
8 |
6 |
Possible Answers for Critical Problems (7, 8, 10, 11)
Problem |
Einstellung Solution |
Direct Solution |
7 |
49 23 3 3 = 20 |
23 3 = 20 |
8 |
39 15 3 3 = 18 |
15 + 3 = 18 |
10 |
48 18 4 4 = 22 |
18 + 4 = 22 |
11 |
36 14 8 8 = 6 |
14 8 = 6 |
Performance of Typical Subjects on Critical Problems
Group |
Einstellung Solution (percent) |
Direct Solution (percent) |
No Solution (percent) |
Control (Children) |
1 |
89 |
10 |
Experimental (Children) |
72 |
24 |
4 |
Control (Adults) |
0 |
100 |
0 |
Experimental (Adults) |
74 |
26 |
0 |
Adapted from Luchins and Luchins (1970).