BOX 3.9
Eating Pie and Learning Fractions
Even small differences in cultural knowledge have the potential to
affect students' learning. For example, a primary school teacher is
helping students to understand fractional parts by using what she thinks
is a commonplace reference. "Today, we're going to talk about cutting
up a Thanksgiving holiday favorite--pumpkin pie." She continues with an
explanation of parts. Well into her discourse, a young African American
boy, looking puzzled, asks, "What is pumpkin pie?" (Tate, 1994).
Most African Americans
are likely to serve sweet potato pie for holiday dinners. In fact, one
of the ways that African American parents explain pumpkin pie to their
children is to say that it is something like sweet potato pie. For
them, sweet potato pie is the common referent. Even the slight
difference of being unfamiliar with pumpkin pie can serve as a source of
interference for the student. Rather than be engaged actively in the
lesson, he may have been preoccupied with trying to imagine pumpkin pie:
What does it taste like? How does it smell? Is its texture chunky
like apple or cherry pie? In the mind of a child, all of these
questions can become more of the focus than the subject of fractions
that the teacher is attempting to teach.